Because it's a horrible idea that fundamentally breaks the game. Also, because the entire premise is incorrect GÇö the problem you're trying to solve doesn't exist, so all you're doing is create new problems for no good reason.

How so?

Does buying a winning soccer team mean you will still win? You have to buy in to play poker so yes you have to pay for your cards.
Buying a character is much different from buying SP. With SP it becomes PLEX for the FOTM, and that is bad it creates dissatisfaction as instant gratification leades to faster boredom.

With character market skill training is not circumvented - someone else spent a lot of time and real money training that character. Bad name, even worse looks and shady history are drawbacks.

Soccer example is bad: you can buy players from other soccer clubs into your team if you have money. Poker example is even worse as it doesnt make any sense.

No, the set limitation in EVE is Time. Buying a character means someone else did it, but time was still spent.

You don't circumvent training, you trade ISK for someone else's time in doing the training and spending their time and money.

Also you didn't answer the question, how so? How has this been breaking the game since 2004?

Have you ever thought where your food comes from? It doesnt magically appear when you pay money, it takes time and effort produce raw material, process it and transport to nearest shop so it would be convenient for you to go and buy. Same with characters in EvE: time and effort were spent, you just purchase the end product.

Let's say a Titan plus char and fittings is somewhere in the low region of 150 Billion. If someone wants to fork out -ú4177 to fly a Titan and lose it, then let them. If they lose it (which they will) and then spend another -ú3338 to get another then they are not 'winning' at Eve, they are merely being stupid with their cash and lot's of other people get play time.

But how does this break the game? Both the char, Titan and fittings, were all existing within the game already. The time and normal game mechanic to create those items were already played out. He merely circumvented the time aspect of the game.
Someone else's time is completely relevant in this regard. If they hadn't spent the time training, buying, building, mining, trading and ratting for those items, they wouldn't exist.

So how has this been breaking Eve since 2004?

How does it? Do they suddenly have skillz with the stuff they get? Does being a noob and owning a Titan make you uber and able to compete in Eve? I think not.

Your stance is also saying those without RL money, can go screw themselves if they wish to play. Nice.

So how has it been breaking Eve since 2004?

That does nothing to make competition pointless. Once on the battlefield SP has little to do with a pilots ability to use there ship.

You really have no idea, do you.

Put your all Vs noob in his deadspace/officer fit vindicator, and send them in to scrap with someone who knows what they're doing in a T2 fit megathron, and see who comes out on top.

Regardless of how pay to win the bazaar might seem, it's offset by the fact that someone had to put both time and money into creating that character and now they're seeking to sell their finished product. Without the time factor, everyone would be in the Fotm without even the slightest delay during, which would usually be offset by a balance pass, but this way everyone is instantly in the most unbalanced ship. And if you couldn't tell, that can easily kill a game.

Edit: got a bit off topic.

This, this right here. Ignore all the bittervets crying about pay to win because this man knows whats going on. That said I still don't think its a clear cut case but it gives us the actual issue. What is better for the EvE comunity as a whole, the value of the high SP characters and the players that may leave if that value was lost or the ability for new characters to catch up to the rest and the potential new players it may bring? This is the real question that needs to be answered.

I'm gamer since over 30 years, I understand more about games like you ever will, trust me that

when the game started the skill time was there to keep the game motivated and stay longer

the more the game lasts the bigger problem and hurdle this becomes for new entrys

thats why this needs some adjustemnt

like I mentioned adding a possibility to buy 1 month of skillpoints with plex every 6 month in addition to the normal skillplan would help a lot and would not damage the mechanic at all

I do not take other games as measurment, as each game has its own logic, in eve more skilltime is needed for the early player, therefore the possibility to purchase more skilltime as an option and again limited maybe between 1-3 month of SP per year would be a good addition to the game, and would not harm anybody

I agree to everybody that the possibility to purchase unlimited skilltime might not be a good idea